Cardinal says spirit of Vatican II has been betrayed

Cardinal says spirit of Vatican II has been betrayed
Cardinal Burke says indiscipline crept in.

Abandonment of internal church discipline over the past half century has undermined the reforms of the Second Vatican Council, said the American cardinal who heads the Vatican’s supreme court.

“This antinomianism embedded in civil society has unfortunately infected post-council ecclesial life,” he said.

“Excitement following the council, linked to the establishment of a new church which teaches freedom and love, has strongly encouraged an attitude of indifference toward church discipline, if not even hostility,” he said. “The reforms of ecclesial life which were hoped for by the council fathers were, therefore, in a certain sense, hindered if not betrayed.”

....ignorance or deliberate neglect of canon law in the years since Vatican II had “reaped gravely harmful fruits in the church,” contributing to the clerical sex abuse scandal, abuses of the liturgy, “vacuous and confused, if not erroneous” religious instruction, lack of discipline among priests and seminarians, rejection of tradition by members of religious orders, disrespect for the church’s teaching on marriage and a “loss of the identity of charitable, educational and health care institutions bearing the name Catholic.”

Link
Jea43216
The Vatican says Vatican II did not invalidate past doctrines. "What was, still is." -Pope Paul VI (pope during Vatican II)
www.vatican.va/…/rc_con_cfaith_d…
Giovanni A. Cattaneo
Well may be it time to suppress the council and move on.
tbswv
I keep hearing all these needed reforms of Vatican II. Can someone please tell me specifically what reforms needed to be made prior to Vatican II? Why was the Council called, what were the expectations of the Council, and how has it improved things in the Catholic Church today?
Excitement following the council, linked to the establishment of a new church which teaches freedom and love...",
What …More
I keep hearing all these needed reforms of Vatican II. Can someone please tell me specifically what reforms needed to be made prior to Vatican II? Why was the Council called, what were the expectations of the Council, and how has it improved things in the Catholic Church today?

Excitement following the council, linked to the establishment of a new church which teaches freedom and love...",
What exactly does this statement mean? The old teach did not teach freedom and love? Did not Pope Pius XII help Jews in Rome during WWII? Does this not show love for his fellow man and preservation of man's dignity and freedom?
Gloria.TV – News Briefs
Comment:
...some councils are necessary and very important, and some councils are not. The Holy Ghost guides the councils and does not allow any heresy, but there is no guarantee that they will be especially significant or useful.
I think that Vatican II was one of the least useful councils in history. There have been others, with which only historians are familiar. Not every council is a Council …More
Comment:

...some councils are necessary and very important, and some councils are not. The Holy Ghost guides the councils and does not allow any heresy, but there is no guarantee that they will be especially significant or useful.

I think that Vatican II was one of the least useful councils in history. There have been others, with which only historians are familiar. Not every council is a Council of Trent or Nicea, as the Pope suggests, without fully explaining what that says about Vatican II.
------------------------------------